Captain America: The New World Order — An Honest Reaction

Author: Joseph Mar 03,2025

Captain America: The New World Order – A Review

Captain America: The New World Order, released February 12th, has received a mixed critical reception. While praised for its action and performances, it's been criticized for narrative shortcomings. This review delves into the film's strengths and weaknesses.

A New Era for Captain America

A New Legacy

Following Steve Rogers' passing of the shield in Avengers: Endgame, Sam Wilson's journey as Captain America continues. The film attempts to blend elements from the previous Captain America trilogy, incorporating wartime themes, espionage, and global settings. The introduction of Joaquin Torres as Sam's partner and the inclusion of familiar, albeit sometimes flawed, CGI effects, are notable aspects. While aiming to establish Sam as a worthy successor to Steve, the film struggles to fully differentiate him, often mirroring Steve's dialogue and demeanor. However, the film does offer moments of levity, particularly in the interactions between Sam and Torres, balancing the serious tone effectively.

Red Hulk

Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

  • Action: The film delivers exciting action sequences, especially those featuring the visually impressive Red Hulk.
  • Performances: Anthony Mackie's portrayal of Sam Wilson is charismatic and physically engaging. Harrison Ford's performance as Secretary Ross adds depth and gravitas.
  • Supporting Cast: Danny Ramirez is a standout as Joaquin Torres, adding energy and dynamism to the team. The main antagonist will resonate with longtime Marvel fans.

Weaknesses:

  • Script: The script suffers from superficial writing, rushed character development, and inconsistencies in Sam's abilities.
  • Predictability: The plot, while initially promising, becomes predictable, relying on familiar Captain America tropes.
  • Character Development: Sam Wilson feels less nuanced than Steve Rogers, and the villain lacks memorability.

Plot Summary Without Spoilers

Plot Overview (Spoiler-Free)

Set after Eternals, the film features Thaddeus Ross as President of the United States, grappling with the colossal threat and potential resource of Tiamut's remains. Sam Wilson is tasked with assembling a new Avengers team, leading to a globe-trotting adventure filled with intrigue and high-stakes action. However, the film's execution falters due to questionable scripting choices, including abrupt plot points and inconsistencies in Sam's capabilities.

Conclusion

Conclusion

Despite its flaws, Captain America: The New World Order provides a solid spy-action experience for casual viewers. Strong visuals, intriguing plot elements, and excellent performances compensate for the weaker script. The post-credits scene hints at future Marvel storylines, leaving viewers wanting more. Whether Sam Wilson fully embodies the Captain America mantle remains to be seen, but the film serves as an acceptable, albeit imperfect, addition to the MCU.

Positive and Negative Aspects Summarized:

Positive: The action sequences, particularly the Red Hulk scenes, and the performances of Mackie and Ford are widely praised. The visual effects are also a highlight.

Negative: The most significant criticism targets the weak and predictable script, underdeveloped characters (especially Sam Wilson and the villain), and inconsistencies in the narrative. The pacing is also considered uneven by some.