Is Anthony Mackie the MCU's Permanent Captain America?

The persistent rumors of Chris Evans' return as Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) stem from the cyclical nature of comic book deaths and rebirths. Steve Rogers' death and subsequent revivals in the comics, mirroring similar storylines for other iconic heroes, fuel speculation. However, the MCU operates differently.

While the comics often see characters resurrected or replaced, the MCU prioritizes permanence. Deaths tend to be final, unlike the comic book world where Steve Rogers has repeatedly reclaimed the Captain America mantle after being seemingly written out. This is highlighted by the continued absence of characters like Malekith, Kaecilius, and Ego.

Anthony Mackie, as Sam Wilson, is now firmly established as Captain America. Mackie himself expresses hope for his continued role, emphasizing that Sam's tenure depends on the success of Captain America: Brave New World. Producers and the director of Brave New World affirm that Sam Wilson is the MCU's Captain America, a permanent fixture, unlike the temporary reigns of Bucky Barnes in the comics.

This emphasis on permanence distinguishes the MCU from its source material, raising the stakes and creating a sense of irreversible consequences. The deaths of Tony Stark and Natasha Romanoff underscore this commitment to finality. Steve Rogers' age, meanwhile, effectively removes him from active duty.

The MCU's future Avengers will likely differ significantly from the original team, with Sam Wilson leading the charge. The studio aims for evolution, not mere repetition, ensuring any future Avengers iteration feels distinct yet worthy of the name. The clear message is: Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson is the MCU's Captain America, and there are no plans for a replacement.

Who has been the best Captain America?

Steve RogersJames "Bucky" BarnesSam WilsonIsaiah BradleyJohn WalkerClint BartonSomeone even more obscure (show off your comic knowledge in the comments!)AnswerSee Results